TO GIVE OR NOT TO GIVE, THAT IS THE QUESTION
HOW TO DEAL WITH PANHANDLERS:
We have all been there, done that? We truly feel compassion for the beggars that we see. We see the news reports about scammers making $300 a day panhandling. We know that some panhandlers want money for drugs or alcohol. We are in a quandry. We do not want to be victims of a con and give our hard earned money to a scoundrel. We do not want to enable alcoholics or druggies to feed their habit. Yet we want to help the needy.
This article gives tips and advice on what to do.
One thing we can do to help feed the hungry is add a non-perishable food item to the boxes for that purpose at grocery store chains. These usually go to food banks.
We can carry small baggies in our cars, purses or brief cases in which we put single serving cans of food with pop-top lids (little pull tab openers like on soda cans-most homeless do not have can openers). If it is needed to consume the food, add plastic spoon or fork. Vienna sausages, tins of fruit, small packs of cookies or donuts, any small items you think of. Instead of money, give a baggie. My eldest daughter and friends used to do this, too.
Before digging and construction began on Sims Bayou, there was a community of homeless that lived under the bridges by Bellfort. Several of them had staked out territories at certain red lights and intersections that were deemed choice spots to panhandle. Drivers who passed on a regular basis became familiar with them and would hold out money or bags of food when they were caught at a red light. Sometimes we would observe turf wars when newcomers or rivals attempted to encroach on another's territory.
A favorite of mine and the Wild Child was an elderly man in a wheel chair. He was a grouchy old cuss, snarled "thank you" in a tone that sounded anything but thankful if he acknowledged you at all, and yet we liked him. His spot was on the esplanade at a red light. Since we always had to make a left turn at that intersection, we would be halted next to him at the red light. One day he was peering into a brown paper bag and loudly complaining about the *bleeping-bleeps* that would give a man all those canned goods without a *bleeping* can opener. In spite of our compassion for the poor man's plight - it's terrible to be hungry and have no way to open cans of food - his wrath struck us as funny and we laughed like fools. Wild Child wanted to go back to my apartment and bring him a can opener. I am sure that the good hearted person who gave him the goods never thought about his lack of an opener and would have been insulted had his comments been heard. It was a potent reminder to us to always give pop top cans or include a can opener.
Most of us have regular routes we travel on errands or jobs. Another favorite of mine and the Wild Child was a heavy set man of indeterminate age that sat on a 5 gal bucket at an underpass intersection where we always turned. He never accosted drivers who stopped there, but if items or money was held out, he would hoist himself to his feet and walk painfully to collect it. Sometimes he had a scruffy little dog at his feet, so Wild Child began putting a baggie of dry dog food in her goodie bag. The man never spoke to us, but the next time we passed his way he held the dog up, as if letting the dog thank us. He came to recognize us and if we caught the green light and couldn't stop, he'd hold up his hand in acknowledgement.
Sure, it is true that some panhandlers are con men and some are chemically dependent. Don't let that curdle your milk of human kindness; it is impossible for us to accurately judge who is truly needy and who do not. If you feel that you want to give, go ahead. A few pieces of change or a dollar isn't much to sacrifice. If you are hesitant, don't. Follow your own conscience. But don't feel guilty.
People say, why don't they go get a job? When you are homeless, no way to maintain a decent wardrobe - even if you manage to keep thieves from stealing your possessions- to maintain good hygeine , it is hard to present yourself in a good light to a prospective employer. There are no washing machines or showers under a bridge or in a park. With no money it is impossible to take public transportation to job hunt. Many homeless have mental health issues are are too unstable to hold a job. Some have been down so long their self esteem and will to try has been beaten into the dirt; they feel hopeless.
Many of the long term homeless are veterans from Vietnam and other conflicts, suffering from PTSD and other mental anguish. Now we are getting a new crop of homeless vets. Some of them also suffer mental and emotional wounds, and some simply cannot find a job and end up on the street, which is a disgrace.
IT IS A NATIONAL DISGRACE!!
The Hard Facts: There are about 500,000 homeless veterans, about 1/3 of the homeless populations . Many suffer mental health issues like PTSD; many ended up homeless because they couldn't get a job.
Homeless Heroes: Veteran unemployment rate higher than rate for non-veterans .
So that disreputable looking panhandler just may be a troubled veteran.
We have all been there, done that? We truly feel compassion for the beggars that we see. We see the news reports about scammers making $300 a day panhandling. We know that some panhandlers want money for drugs or alcohol. We are in a quandry. We do not want to be victims of a con and give our hard earned money to a scoundrel. We do not want to enable alcoholics or druggies to feed their habit. Yet we want to help the needy.
This article gives tips and advice on what to do.
One thing we can do to help feed the hungry is add a non-perishable food item to the boxes for that purpose at grocery store chains. These usually go to food banks.
We can carry small baggies in our cars, purses or brief cases in which we put single serving cans of food with pop-top lids (little pull tab openers like on soda cans-most homeless do not have can openers). If it is needed to consume the food, add plastic spoon or fork. Vienna sausages, tins of fruit, small packs of cookies or donuts, any small items you think of. Instead of money, give a baggie. My eldest daughter and friends used to do this, too.
Before digging and construction began on Sims Bayou, there was a community of homeless that lived under the bridges by Bellfort. Several of them had staked out territories at certain red lights and intersections that were deemed choice spots to panhandle. Drivers who passed on a regular basis became familiar with them and would hold out money or bags of food when they were caught at a red light. Sometimes we would observe turf wars when newcomers or rivals attempted to encroach on another's territory.
A favorite of mine and the Wild Child was an elderly man in a wheel chair. He was a grouchy old cuss, snarled "thank you" in a tone that sounded anything but thankful if he acknowledged you at all, and yet we liked him. His spot was on the esplanade at a red light. Since we always had to make a left turn at that intersection, we would be halted next to him at the red light. One day he was peering into a brown paper bag and loudly complaining about the *bleeping-bleeps* that would give a man all those canned goods without a *bleeping* can opener. In spite of our compassion for the poor man's plight - it's terrible to be hungry and have no way to open cans of food - his wrath struck us as funny and we laughed like fools. Wild Child wanted to go back to my apartment and bring him a can opener. I am sure that the good hearted person who gave him the goods never thought about his lack of an opener and would have been insulted had his comments been heard. It was a potent reminder to us to always give pop top cans or include a can opener.
Most of us have regular routes we travel on errands or jobs. Another favorite of mine and the Wild Child was a heavy set man of indeterminate age that sat on a 5 gal bucket at an underpass intersection where we always turned. He never accosted drivers who stopped there, but if items or money was held out, he would hoist himself to his feet and walk painfully to collect it. Sometimes he had a scruffy little dog at his feet, so Wild Child began putting a baggie of dry dog food in her goodie bag. The man never spoke to us, but the next time we passed his way he held the dog up, as if letting the dog thank us. He came to recognize us and if we caught the green light and couldn't stop, he'd hold up his hand in acknowledgement.
Sure, it is true that some panhandlers are con men and some are chemically dependent. Don't let that curdle your milk of human kindness; it is impossible for us to accurately judge who is truly needy and who do not. If you feel that you want to give, go ahead. A few pieces of change or a dollar isn't much to sacrifice. If you are hesitant, don't. Follow your own conscience. But don't feel guilty.
People say, why don't they go get a job? When you are homeless, no way to maintain a decent wardrobe - even if you manage to keep thieves from stealing your possessions- to maintain good hygeine , it is hard to present yourself in a good light to a prospective employer. There are no washing machines or showers under a bridge or in a park. With no money it is impossible to take public transportation to job hunt. Many homeless have mental health issues are are too unstable to hold a job. Some have been down so long their self esteem and will to try has been beaten into the dirt; they feel hopeless.
Many of the long term homeless are veterans from Vietnam and other conflicts, suffering from PTSD and other mental anguish. Now we are getting a new crop of homeless vets. Some of them also suffer mental and emotional wounds, and some simply cannot find a job and end up on the street, which is a disgrace.
IT IS A NATIONAL DISGRACE!!
The Hard Facts: There are about 500,000 homeless veterans, about 1/3 of the homeless populations . Many suffer mental health issues like PTSD; many ended up homeless because they couldn't get a job.
Homeless Heroes: Veteran unemployment rate higher than rate for non-veterans .
So that disreputable looking panhandler just may be a troubled veteran.
6 Comments:
At Tuesday, August 01, 2006 1:10:00 PM , yellowdoggranny said...
when i was working in manassas, virginia back in 91 i would always use the same fast food place to get lunch and there was always this one guy at the end of the curb when you drove out and i would almost always give him my change...i mentioned it one day at work and they all laughed at me...the asst. manager took me in his car to this really nice apartment complex and pointed out a apt.said that is where the guy lives...I freaked..i said but i have seen him digging in the fast food resturant's garbage cans for food..he said he is eating out of a carton that his wife brings him every day...in a brand new car...she sets it in the garbage can and he eats out of it..food she either made or bought for him...the kid said he probably made 200 hundred a day at that fast food place with people giving him all their change when they came thru....so that has changed my ideas about pan handling..plus san francisco's pan handlers were so pushy and demanding...turned me off..i always gave to the women though...
At Tuesday, August 01, 2006 10:32:00 PM , Ingrid said...
When we moved to Austin the first year, we lived in the East part of town in 'student'/immigrant ville. There was this one lady in her late 40s (I think, she was not that much older than me but just looked 'worn') and one time, I had talked to her before that day when she just told me as a matter of fact, that she was starving, and I handed her a brown paper bag with a water, ham and cheese sandwhich, banana and a coke, and her eyes got big and she got teary, the light turned green and the look of gratefulness as she just quickly started to eat as we were pulling up to turn onto the next street..it was too much for me. I almost cried but kept it inside because I was driving and my kids were looking at me funny, but it cut me deeply. How hungry was she.. and how honestly happy she was that someone gave her food, it made me so ashamed and so sad , sad beyond belief. There was no faking there.. I still think of her to this day and hope that she's ok, somehow. And to think that they built this big ass million dollar shelter for the homeless that cannot even house that many plus is downtown where not everyone can get to..it's crazy.
Food and drinks is what I'd give, rather than money.
Ingrid
At Tuesday, August 01, 2006 10:37:00 PM , JBlue said...
Good post about an ongoing problem, WA.
At Wednesday, August 02, 2006 12:49:00 AM , Jolly Roger said...
I never minded giving them the money if I knew they were going to get drunk.
If I found myself in a similar condition, I have a feeling I'd be looking to dull the blade myself.
At Friday, August 04, 2006 11:59:00 PM , Marty said...
I know a few of those homeless well. Both the church I work for and the one I used to attend have homeless ministries. I always keep a roll of dollar bills in my car for that very reason.
Three of those homeless joined the church where I work. One of them is still attending regularly after 5 years. He hangs out on Bellfort feeding the pidgeons and selling newspapers. The other two have passed on. One of them, Marc, was enrolled in a nearby college and was on his way home one evening on his bicycle when he was hit by a car and killed. Little Joe passed away not long before Marc. Years of drinking and drugging finally got the best of him even though he had changed his ways. Marc "hung his sign" on Monroe and Fuqua. Little Joe was Marc's friend, but he didn't beg. He had a job that paid him just enough to eat and live at the Smile Inn. Of course, there was always the food pantry at the church.
By the way, I've "TAGGED" both you and Granny on my blog tonight.
At Sunday, August 06, 2006 8:53:00 AM , Xpatriated Texan said...
I often give money to the homeless. My granny used to get all upity about homeless people and said things like, "If you give them money, they'll just spend it on booze."
Maybe. As a Christian, I've been told to give money to the poor. I haven't been told to give it to them only if they spend it the way I think they should.
XT
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home